@Elf: Thanks for that phrase “messy etiology”—it’s awesome. However, where do you get the connection between sharp distinctions and ANTI-sphexishness? My understanding is that Eliezer’s preference for sharp distinctions leads to PRO-sphexishness. By “pro-sphexishness” I mean considering hardwired values the foundation of morality, to be elevated and celebrated, not denigrated.
@Elf: Thanks for that phrase “messy etiology”—it’s awesome. However, where do you get the connection between sharp distinctions and ANTI-sphexishness? My understanding is that Eliezer’s preference for sharp distinctions leads to PRO-sphexishness. By “pro-sphexishness” I mean considering hardwired values the foundation of morality, to be elevated and celebrated, not denigrated.