This argument begs the question, it is only works if God does not exist.
You’re trying to prove that there is no God, and everything is created naturally.
Your say:
All of our opinions about what is naturally possible must be based, by definition, on observations of nature.
This statement is correct if there is no outside force helping the Universe along.
But if there is a God then what you are observing is not natural, it was put in place, or at least helped along, by a divine being.
Note that I am an atheist, this is just a standard rebuttal.
This argument begs the question, it is only works if God does not exist. You’re trying to prove that there is no God, and everything is created naturally.
Your say:
This statement is correct if there is no outside force helping the Universe along. But if there is a God then what you are observing is not natural, it was put in place, or at least helped along, by a divine being.
Note that I am an atheist, this is just a standard rebuttal.