Certain texts are characterized by precision, such as mathematical proofs, standard operating procedures, code, protocols, and laws. Their authority, power, and usefulness stem from this quality. Criticizing them for being imprecise is justified.
Nope; precision has nothing to do with intrinsic value. If Ashley asks Blaine to get her an apple from the fridge, many would agree that ‘apple’ is a rather specific thing, but if Blaine was insistent on being dense he can still say “Really? An apple? How vague! There are so many possible subatomic configurations that could correspond to an apple, and if you don’t have an exact preference ordering of sub-atomically specified apple configurations, then you’re an incoherent agent without a proper utility function!”
And Blaine, by the way, is speaking the truth here; Ashley could in fact be more specific. Ashley is not being completely vague, however; ‘apple’ is specific enough to specify a range of things, and within that range it may be ambiguous as to what she wants from the perspective of someone who is strangely obsessed with specificity, but Ashley can in fact simply and directly want every single apple that matches her rangerately-specified criteria.
So it is with words like ‘Good’, ‘Relevant’, ‘Considerate’, ‘Justice’, and ‘Intrinsic Value Strategicism’.
Nope; precision has nothing to do with intrinsic value. If Ashley asks Blaine to get her an apple from the fridge, many would agree that ‘apple’ is a rather specific thing, but if Blaine was insistent on being dense he can still say “Really? An apple? How vague! There are so many possible subatomic configurations that could correspond to an apple, and if you don’t have an exact preference ordering of sub-atomically specified apple configurations, then you’re an incoherent agent without a proper utility function!”
And Blaine, by the way, is speaking the truth here; Ashley could in fact be more specific. Ashley is not being completely vague, however; ‘apple’ is specific enough to specify a range of things, and within that range it may be ambiguous as to what she wants from the perspective of someone who is strangely obsessed with specificity, but Ashley can in fact simply and directly want every single apple that matches her rangerately-specified criteria.
So it is with words like ‘Good’, ‘Relevant’, ‘Considerate’, ‘Justice’, and ‘Intrinsic Value Strategicism’.