My own guesses are that CFAR mostly paid an [amount of attention that made sense] to reducing psychosis/mania risks in the workshop context, after our initial bad experience with the mania/psychosis episode at an early workshop when we did not yet realize this could be a thing.
The things we did:
tried to screen for instablity;
tried to warn people who we thought might have some risk factors (but not enough risk factors that we were screening them out) after accepting them to the workshop, and before they’d had a chance to say yes. (We’d standardly say something like: “we don’t ask questions this nosy, and you’re already in regardless, but, just so you know, there’s some evidence that workshops of all sorts, probably including CFAR workshops, may increase risks of mania or psychosis in people with vulnerability to that, so if you have any sort of psychiatric history you may want to consider either not coming, or talking about it with a psychiatrist before coming.”)
try to train our instructors and “mentors” (curriculum volunteers) to notice warning signs. check in as a staff regularly to see if anyone had noticed any warning signs for any participants. if sensible, talk to the participant to encourage them to sleep more, skip classes, avoid recreational drugs for awhile, do normal grounding activities, etc. (This happened relatively often — maybe once every three workshops — but was usually a relatively minor matter. Eg this would be a person who was having trouble sleeping and who perhaps thought they had a chance at solving [some long-standing personal problem they’d previously given up on] “right now” a way that weirded us out, but who also seemed pretty normal and reasonable still.)
I separately think I put a reasonable amount of effort into organizing basic community support and first aid for those who were socially contiguous with me/CFAR who were having acutely bad mental health times, although my own capacities weren’t enough for a growing community and I mostly gave up on the less near-me parts around 2018.
It mostly did not occur to me to contemplate our cultural impact on the community’s overall psychosis rate (except for trying for awhile to discourage tulpas and other risky practices, and to discourage associating with people who did such things, and then giving up on this around 2018 when it seemed to me there was no real remaining chance of quarantining these practices).
I like the line of inquiry about “what art of rationality might be both good in itself, and increase peoples’ robustness / decrease their vulnerability to mania/psychosis-type failure modes, including much milder versions that may be fairly common in these parts and that are still bad”. I’ll be pursuing it. I take your point that I could in principle have pursued it earlier.
If we are going to be doing a fault analysis in which we give me and CFAR responsibility for some of our downstream memetic effects, I’d like CFAR to also get some credit for any good downstream memetic effects we had. My own guess is that CFAR workshops:
made it possible for EA and “the rationalist community” to expand a great deal without becoming nearly as “diluted”/“normie” as would’ve happened by default, with that level of immigration-per-year;
helped many “straw lesswrongers” to become more “agenty” and realize “problems are for solving” instead of sort of staring helplessly at their todo lists and desires, and that this part made the rationalist community stronger and healthier
helped a fair number of people to become less “straw EA” in the sense of “my only duty is to do the greatest good for the greatest number, while ignoring my feelings”, and to tune in a bit more to some of the basics of healthy life, sometimes.
I acknowledge that these alleged benefits are my personal guesses and may be wrong. But these guesses seem on par to me with my personal guess that patterns of messing with one’s own functioning (as from “CFAR techniques”) can erode psychological wholeness, and I’m afraid it’ll be confusing if I voice only the negative parts of my personal guesses.
My own guesses are that CFAR mostly paid an [amount of attention that made sense] to reducing psychosis/mania risks in the workshop context, after our initial bad experience with the mania/psychosis episode at an early workshop when we did not yet realize this could be a thing.
The things we did:
tried to screen for instablity;
tried to warn people who we thought might have some risk factors (but not enough risk factors that we were screening them out) after accepting them to the workshop, and before they’d had a chance to say yes. (We’d standardly say something like: “we don’t ask questions this nosy, and you’re already in regardless, but, just so you know, there’s some evidence that workshops of all sorts, probably including CFAR workshops, may increase risks of mania or psychosis in people with vulnerability to that, so if you have any sort of psychiatric history you may want to consider either not coming, or talking about it with a psychiatrist before coming.”)
try to train our instructors and “mentors” (curriculum volunteers) to notice warning signs. check in as a staff regularly to see if anyone had noticed any warning signs for any participants. if sensible, talk to the participant to encourage them to sleep more, skip classes, avoid recreational drugs for awhile, do normal grounding activities, etc. (This happened relatively often — maybe once every three workshops — but was usually a relatively minor matter. Eg this would be a person who was having trouble sleeping and who perhaps thought they had a chance at solving [some long-standing personal problem they’d previously given up on] “right now” a way that weirded us out, but who also seemed pretty normal and reasonable still.)
I separately think I put a reasonable amount of effort into organizing basic community support and first aid for those who were socially contiguous with me/CFAR who were having acutely bad mental health times, although my own capacities weren’t enough for a growing community and I mostly gave up on the less near-me parts around 2018.
It mostly did not occur to me to contemplate our cultural impact on the community’s overall psychosis rate (except for trying for awhile to discourage tulpas and other risky practices, and to discourage associating with people who did such things, and then giving up on this around 2018 when it seemed to me there was no real remaining chance of quarantining these practices).
I like the line of inquiry about “what art of rationality might be both good in itself, and increase peoples’ robustness / decrease their vulnerability to mania/psychosis-type failure modes, including much milder versions that may be fairly common in these parts and that are still bad”. I’ll be pursuing it. I take your point that I could in principle have pursued it earlier.
If we are going to be doing a fault analysis in which we give me and CFAR responsibility for some of our downstream memetic effects, I’d like CFAR to also get some credit for any good downstream memetic effects we had. My own guess is that CFAR workshops:
made it possible for EA and “the rationalist community” to expand a great deal without becoming nearly as “diluted”/“normie” as would’ve happened by default, with that level of immigration-per-year;
helped many “straw lesswrongers” to become more “agenty” and realize “problems are for solving” instead of sort of staring helplessly at their todo lists and desires, and that this part made the rationalist community stronger and healthier
helped a fair number of people to become less “straw EA” in the sense of “my only duty is to do the greatest good for the greatest number, while ignoring my feelings”, and to tune in a bit more to some of the basics of healthy life, sometimes.
I acknowledge that these alleged benefits are my personal guesses and may be wrong. But these guesses seem on par to me with my personal guess that patterns of messing with one’s own functioning (as from “CFAR techniques”) can erode psychological wholeness, and I’m afraid it’ll be confusing if I voice only the negative parts of my personal guesses.