I wish the post more strongly emphasized that regulation was a key part of the picture
I feel like it does emphasize that, about as strongly as is possible? The second step in my story of how RSPs make things go well is that the government has to step in and use them as a basis for regulation.
I think the post could directly say “voluntary RSPs seem unlikely to suffice (and wouldn’t be pauses done right), but …”.
I agree it does emphasize the importance of regulation pretty strongly.
Part of my perspective is that the title implies a conclusion which isn’t quite right and so it would have been good (at least with the benefit of hindsight) to clarify this explicitly. At least to the extent you agree with me.
I feel like it does emphasize that, about as strongly as is possible? The second step in my story of how RSPs make things go well is that the government has to step in and use them as a basis for regulation.
I think the post could directly say “voluntary RSPs seem unlikely to suffice (and wouldn’t be pauses done right), but …”.
I agree it does emphasize the importance of regulation pretty strongly.
Part of my perspective is that the title implies a conclusion which isn’t quite right and so it would have been good (at least with the benefit of hindsight) to clarify this explicitly. At least to the extent you agree with me.