Perhaps I’m misunderstanding your objection but I think the issue is that Claude is hosted on AWS servers (among other places), which means Amazon could steal Claude’s model weights if it wanted to, and ASL-3 states that Claude needs to be secure against theft by other companies (including Amazon).
I don’t know for sure that Zach’s assertion is true, but I’m reasonably confident that a dedicated Amazon security team could steal the contents of any AWS server if they really wanted to.
Huh? Simply using someone else’s hosting doesn’t mean that Amazon has a threat-modeled ability to steal Claude’s model weights.
For example, it could be the case (not saying it is, this is just illustrative) that Amazon has given Anthropic sufficient surveillance capabilities inside their data centers that combined with other controls the risk is low.
Perhaps I’m misunderstanding your objection but I think the issue is that Claude is hosted on AWS servers (among other places), which means Amazon could steal Claude’s model weights if it wanted to, and ASL-3 states that Claude needs to be secure against theft by other companies (including Amazon).
I don’t know for sure that Zach’s assertion is true, but I’m reasonably confident that a dedicated Amazon security team could steal the contents of any AWS server if they really wanted to.
Huh? Simply using someone else’s hosting doesn’t mean that Amazon has a threat-modeled ability to steal Claude’s model weights.
For example, it could be the case (not saying it is, this is just illustrative) that Amazon has given Anthropic sufficient surveillance capabilities inside their data centers that combined with other controls the risk is low.