Thanks! I think you’re right that this isn’t conclusive evidence; trying on a different setting where self awareness isn’t so similar to the in distribution behavior might help, which I’m planning on looking at next. I do think that you shouldn’t draw much from the absolute magnitude of the effect at a given layer for a given dataset, since the questions in each dataset are totally different (the relative magnitude across layers is a more principled thing to compare, which is why we argued they looked similar).
Thanks! I think you’re right that this isn’t conclusive evidence; trying on a different setting where self awareness isn’t so similar to the in distribution behavior might help, which I’m planning on looking at next. I do think that you shouldn’t draw much from the absolute magnitude of the effect at a given layer for a given dataset, since the questions in each dataset are totally different (the relative magnitude across layers is a more principled thing to compare, which is why we argued they looked similar).