I didn’t read the post particularly carefully, it’s totally plausible that I’m misunderstanding the key ideas you were trying to convey. I apologise for phrasing my claims in a way that made it sound like I was skeptical of your motivations; I’m not, and I’m glad you wrote this up.
I think my concerns still apply to the position you stated in the previous comment, but insofar as the main motivation behind my comment was to generically nudge LW in a certain direction, I’ll try to do this more directly, rather than via poking at individual posts in an opportunistic way.
I didn’t read the post particularly carefully, it’s totally plausible that I’m misunderstanding the key ideas you were trying to convey. I apologise for phrasing my claims in a way that made it sound like I was skeptical of your motivations; I’m not, and I’m glad you wrote this up.
I think my concerns still apply to the position you stated in the previous comment, but insofar as the main motivation behind my comment was to generically nudge LW in a certain direction, I’ll try to do this more directly, rather than via poking at individual posts in an opportunistic way.