The confusion on this question is the assumption that there can be only one “you”. There is no logical contradiction in having a you arrive at both locations. There are now two yous. They’re not the same you, but they are both yous—they have your memories, beliefs, and habits. They’ll diverge in experiences from there, but they are equally you.
There’s an intuition that physical continuity is important, but on examination it’s just not true. What we mean by “me” is a set of memories, beliefs, and habits. The continuity of those is what matters. That’s what defines you.
The confusion on this question is the assumption that there can be only one “you”. There is no logical contradiction in having a you arrive at both locations. There are now two yous. They’re not the same you, but they are both yous—they have your memories, beliefs, and habits. They’ll diverge in experiences from there, but they are equally you.
There’s an intuition that physical continuity is important, but on examination it’s just not true. What we mean by “me” is a set of memories, beliefs, and habits. The continuity of those is what matters. That’s what defines you.