This is too strong. For example, releasing the product would be correct if someone else would do something similar soon anyway and you’re safer than them and releasing first lets you capture more of the free energy. (That’s not the case here, but it’s not as straightforward as you suggest, especially with your “Regardless of how good their alignment plans are” and your claim “There’s just no good reason to do that, except short-term greed”.)
This is too strong. For example, releasing the product would be correct if someone else would do something similar soon anyway and you’re safer than them and releasing first lets you capture more of the free energy. (That’s not the case here, but it’s not as straightforward as you suggest, especially with your “Regardless of how good their alignment plans are” and your claim “There’s just no good reason to do that, except short-term greed”.)