It bothers me there’s no really established terminology for different views on personal identity. As in, whether you treat selves or persons essentially as “ontological primitives” or not. There’s a bunch of terms out there, but they are all sort of awkward for one reason or another and in any case I find there isn’t anything as widely established and easily understood as something like metaethical positions, i.e. moral realism vs anti-realism for example.
There isn’t really a snappy term to communicate something like “I don’t think the Star Trek teleporter kills me because I think my identity isn’t defined on any basic unchanging essence or specific atoms blah blah.” Except, if you’re a Buddhist. But if you’ve come to these views from totally different sources and know next to nothing about actual Buddhist traditions, calling yourself a Buddhist seems wrong. Using the term anattā isn’t too bad I suppose, but something without the Buddhist baggage would be more ideal.
It bothers me there’s no really established terminology for different views on personal identity. As in, whether you treat selves or persons essentially as “ontological primitives” or not. There’s a bunch of terms out there, but they are all sort of awkward for one reason or another and in any case I find there isn’t anything as widely established and easily understood as something like metaethical positions, i.e. moral realism vs anti-realism for example.
There isn’t really a snappy term to communicate something like “I don’t think the Star Trek teleporter kills me because I think my identity isn’t defined on any basic unchanging essence or specific atoms blah blah.” Except, if you’re a Buddhist. But if you’ve come to these views from totally different sources and know next to nothing about actual Buddhist traditions, calling yourself a Buddhist seems wrong. Using the term anattā isn’t too bad I suppose, but something without the Buddhist baggage would be more ideal.
There are the terms “closed individualism,” “open individualism,” and “empty individualism” used in this Qualia Computing post.