Again, you’re using the word “evidence” differently from everyone else. This only serves to confuse the discussion.
Tabooing “evidence”, what I was saying is that a BB would have the same initial brain-state (what I termed “evidence”) and therefore would achieve the same final brain-state (what I termed “conclusions”). The laws of physics for its brain-state evolution, and the physical causality between the two states, are the same as for your brain. This is trivially so by the very definition of a BB that is sufficiently similar to your brain.
I don’t know what you mean by “externalist evidence” and I don’t see how it would matter. The considerations that apply here are exactly the same as in Eliezer’s discussion of p-zombies. Imagine a BB which is a slightly larger fluctuation than a mere brain; it is a fluctuation of a whole body, which can live for a few seconds, and can speak and think in that time. It would think and say “I am conscious” for the same reasons as you do; therefore it is not a p-zombie. It would think and say “Barack Obama exists” for the same reasons as you do; therefore what everyone-but-you calls its knowledge and its beliefs about “Barack Obama”, are of the same kind as yours.
Again, you’re using the word “evidence” differently from everyone else. This only serves to confuse the discussion.
Tabooing “evidence”, what I was saying is that a BB would have the same initial brain-state (what I termed “evidence”) and therefore would achieve the same final brain-state (what I termed “conclusions”). The laws of physics for its brain-state evolution, and the physical causality between the two states, are the same as for your brain. This is trivially so by the very definition of a BB that is sufficiently similar to your brain.
I don’t know what you mean by “externalist evidence” and I don’t see how it would matter. The considerations that apply here are exactly the same as in Eliezer’s discussion of p-zombies. Imagine a BB which is a slightly larger fluctuation than a mere brain; it is a fluctuation of a whole body, which can live for a few seconds, and can speak and think in that time. It would think and say “I am conscious” for the same reasons as you do; therefore it is not a p-zombie. It would think and say “Barack Obama exists” for the same reasons as you do; therefore what everyone-but-you calls its knowledge and its beliefs about “Barack Obama”, are of the same kind as yours.