I would hypothesise that it is more about the underlying ability to use the engine that is intelligence. If we do the classic eliezer definition (i think it is in the sequences at least) of the ability to hit a target then that is only half of the problem because you have to choose a problem space as well.
Part of intelligence is probably choosing a good problem space but I think the information sampling and the general knowledge level of the people and institutions and general information sources around you is quite important to that sampling process. Hence if you’re better at integrating diverse sources of information then you’re likely better at making progress.
Finally I think there’s something about some weird sort of scientific version of frame control where a lot of science is about asking the right question and getting exposure to more ways of asking questions lead to better ways of asking questions.
So to use your intelligence you need to wield it well and wielding it well partly involves working on the right questions. But if you’re not smart enough to solve the questions in the first place it doesn’t really matter if you ask the right question.
I would hypothesise that it is more about the underlying ability to use the engine that is intelligence. If we do the classic eliezer definition (i think it is in the sequences at least) of the ability to hit a target then that is only half of the problem because you have to choose a problem space as well.
Part of intelligence is probably choosing a good problem space but I think the information sampling and the general knowledge level of the people and institutions and general information sources around you is quite important to that sampling process. Hence if you’re better at integrating diverse sources of information then you’re likely better at making progress.
Finally I think there’s something about some weird sort of scientific version of frame control where a lot of science is about asking the right question and getting exposure to more ways of asking questions lead to better ways of asking questions.
So to use your intelligence you need to wield it well and wielding it well partly involves working on the right questions. But if you’re not smart enough to solve the questions in the first place it doesn’t really matter if you ask the right question.