“Our monkey tribe good! Therefore nobody from our monkey tribe ever do bad thing!”
Don’t forget Wittgenstein may have reacted as he did out his own emotional attachment as well.
“Who you to say your monkey tribe so much better than mine!”
Which is not to imply that he was identifying with Nazis, which he obviously wasn’t, but you would be surprised how many historic accounts of those of say Jewish descent that fled the National Socialist regime still overall held German and Austrian culture and “national character” in higher esteem than that of say the British, Russians or Americans, we have.
“If my monkey tribe can do horrible things, well yours isn’t that different!”
Don’t forget Wittgenstein may have reacted as he did out his own emotional attachment as well.
“Who you to say your monkey tribe so much better than mine!”
Agreed. Or from e.g. feeling betrayed that Malcolm didn’t consider him and Wittgenstein to belong in the same monkey tribe for all intends and purposes. I’ve not read any of Wittgenstein, but if he was of internationalist ideology, he might have been disappointed to see nationalist sentiment in Malcolm (which would put Malcolm and Wittgenstein in different tribes) rather than whatever ideological/political/racial/religious/class distinctions would have put them in the same tribe.
I don’t make the same tribal distinctions that a Greek nationalist would make, or a white nationalist would make. For someone to put much weight on such distinctions would mark him as a different tribe according to my distinctions, even though I’m Greek and white too.
This makes me think of one of those intellectual hipster Hegelian dialectic thingies.
Idiot: My monkeys are better than your monkeys. (Blood for the blood god, etc; Malcolm.)
Contrarian: My monkeys are better than your monkeys, because they don’t say things like “My monkeys are better than your monkeys.” (Secular Western cosmopolitanism, faith in progress, etc; Wittgenstein.)
Hipster: My monkeys are better than your monkeys, because they don’t say things like “My monkeys are better than your monkeys, because they don’t say things like ‘My monkeys are better than your monkeys.’” (Postmodernism, cultural relativism, etc; Vladimir.)
It amuses me that I can think of a few trendy Continentals right now who base their appeal on working at level four.
Don’t forget Wittgenstein may have reacted as he did out his own emotional attachment as well.
“Who you to say your monkey tribe so much better than mine!”
Which is not to imply that he was identifying with Nazis, which he obviously wasn’t, but you would be surprised how many historic accounts of those of say Jewish descent that fled the National Socialist regime still overall held German and Austrian culture and “national character” in higher esteem than that of say the British, Russians or Americans, we have.
“If my monkey tribe can do horrible things, well yours isn’t that different!”
Agreed. Or from e.g. feeling betrayed that Malcolm didn’t consider him and Wittgenstein to belong in the same monkey tribe for all intends and purposes. I’ve not read any of Wittgenstein, but if he was of internationalist ideology, he might have been disappointed to see nationalist sentiment in Malcolm (which would put Malcolm and Wittgenstein in different tribes) rather than whatever ideological/political/racial/religious/class distinctions would have put them in the same tribe.
I don’t make the same tribal distinctions that a Greek nationalist would make, or a white nationalist would make. For someone to put much weight on such distinctions would mark him as a different tribe according to my distinctions, even though I’m Greek and white too.
This makes me think of one of those intellectual hipster Hegelian dialectic thingies.
Idiot: My monkeys are better than your monkeys. (Blood for the blood god, etc; Malcolm.)
Contrarian: My monkeys are better than your monkeys, because they don’t say things like “My monkeys are better than your monkeys.” (Secular Western cosmopolitanism, faith in progress, etc; Wittgenstein.)
Hipster: My monkeys are better than your monkeys, because they don’t say things like “My monkeys are better than your monkeys, because they don’t say things like ‘My monkeys are better than your monkeys.’” (Postmodernism, cultural relativism, etc; Vladimir.)
It amuses me that I can think of a few trendy Continentals right now who base their appeal on working at level four.
People can get very upset when those they like, “suddenly” turn out not to be “part” of the same tribe.