Certain desires help the human race, other desires hurt the human race, and these can be discovered in the same way we discover any other facts about the universe.
You simply passed the recursive buck to “help” and “hurt”. I will let you take for granted the superintelligence’s knowledge of, or well-calibrated probability distribution over, any empirical truth about consequences; but when it comes to the valuation of those consequences in terms of “helping” or “hurting” you must tell me how to compute it, or run a computation that computes how to compute it.
Certain desires help the human race, other desires hurt the human race, and these can be discovered in the same way we discover any other facts about the universe.
You simply passed the recursive buck to “help” and “hurt”. I will let you take for granted the superintelligence’s knowledge of, or well-calibrated probability distribution over, any empirical truth about consequences; but when it comes to the valuation of those consequences in terms of “helping” or “hurting” you must tell me how to compute it, or run a computation that computes how to compute it.