Then one of the two “I diet, I am overweight” options seems appropriate, depending on whether you exercise or not. Whether you have lost or gained weight recently doesn’t seem part of the poll.
A question not being very “well formulated” implies to me that it incorporates confusions, ambiguities, false dilemmas, etc.
That a different question might be more relevant to the purpose of the post, seems a different issue.
I was very careful to formulate the question to avoid confusions, particularly in the definition of ‘overweight’ (my thinking was, Obelix would claim he was not overweight, by defining ‘overweight’ I at least ensure that different definitions of ‘overweight’ do not blur the line). In the process, I did not consider the case of a person who had relatively recently started a diet (or an exercise regimen) and whose weight had changed as a result, but not sufficiently to move past the arbitrary 25 BMI line.
This was therefore probably not the best way to phrase the question, and for that I apologise (if I were to go back in time and rewrite the question, I would take that case into account). Nonetheless, the question stands as is; I think that it is more important at this point to be consistent, and thus one of the “I diet, I am overweight” options are appropriate.
This question is not very well formulated. I diet, and have lost 30 pounds or so since last december but am still overweight
Then one of the two “I diet, I am overweight” options seems appropriate, depending on whether you exercise or not. Whether you have lost or gained weight recently doesn’t seem part of the poll.
I’m saying that losing 30 pounds appears to be exactly the sort of thing we’re actually trying to find out about but the poll doesn’t check for it.
A question not being very “well formulated” implies to me that it incorporates confusions, ambiguities, false dilemmas, etc. That a different question might be more relevant to the purpose of the post, seems a different issue.
I was very careful to formulate the question to avoid confusions, particularly in the definition of ‘overweight’ (my thinking was, Obelix would claim he was not overweight, by defining ‘overweight’ I at least ensure that different definitions of ‘overweight’ do not blur the line). In the process, I did not consider the case of a person who had relatively recently started a diet (or an exercise regimen) and whose weight had changed as a result, but not sufficiently to move past the arbitrary 25 BMI line.
This was therefore probably not the best way to phrase the question, and for that I apologise (if I were to go back in time and rewrite the question, I would take that case into account). Nonetheless, the question stands as is; I think that it is more important at this point to be consistent, and thus one of the “I diet, I am overweight” options are appropriate.