Very few people disobey orders because they think they will be vindicated by events. It is far more common for people to disobey orders for purposes of personal gain or out of laziness, fear, or other considerations. The person, especially the soldier, who disobeys a direct order from recognized authority on either moral or tactical grounds is an uncommon scenario.
It may be an uncommon scenario, but it’s the scenario that’s under discussion. We’re talking about situations where a soldier has orders to do one thing, and believes that moral or tactical considerations require them to do something else—and we’re asking what ethical injunctions should apply in that scenario.
To be fair, Jubilee wasn’t very specific about that.
Very few people disobey orders because they think they will be vindicated by events. It is far more common for people to disobey orders for purposes of personal gain or out of laziness, fear, or other considerations. The person, especially the soldier, who disobeys a direct order from recognized authority on either moral or tactical grounds is an uncommon scenario.
It may be an uncommon scenario, but it’s the scenario that’s under discussion. We’re talking about situations where a soldier has orders to do one thing, and believes that moral or tactical considerations require them to do something else—and we’re asking what ethical injunctions should apply in that scenario.
To be fair, Jubilee wasn’t very specific about that.