Here’s another question, though: Will it drive 5% of my reading audience sane?
There are people who really, genuinely feel there’s no point in striving to live, because life isn’t nice. Even just showing them that life could be nice might be helpful, when it comes to things like getting signed up for cryonics.
Is showing them a fictional nicer life really actually going to help, here? I mean, I could be wrong—there was that whole religion thing—but I’d think that what people like that need would be a nicer life now and showing them a better world would tend to make them unhappier.
In one very specific case, it well might. It’s someone who will, no question about it, be dead within a year.
His main objection to cryonics seems to be that living isn’t very fun anyway, so why bother. And though I may be playing whack-a-mole with arguments, life is important enough to at least try.
I’d just like to say here, that a few months ago, reading the fun theory sequence made me much happier. It was the idea that there was at least one, probably more, good futures, with a clear way of how to get there. Before, I had just assumed that we would all die in some apocalypse, probably from climate change. So thank you.
That’s a great sentiment, but it doesn’t take into account that people who “genuinely feel there’s no point in striving to live” are typically clinically depressed. I.E., have a serious issue with their neurochemistry.
Take it from someone who’s been there; you don’t talk someone out of a depression, at least not unless you’re a psychiatrist with a pad of prescription sheets and training in cognitive behavioral therapy. Or at least an ECT machine and a really kinky looking table. God I love psychiatry.
(If on the other hand we’re just talking about people who are bummed, not actually having given up on life, then yeah I’m sure EY could spin a tale good enough to pick up their spirits.)
I’ve had people try to dissuade me in cryonics discussions on the basis that it simply wouldn’t be worth it, life isn’t that great. I doubt they were clinically depressed. Whether that was their true rejection, on the other hand...
Yeah, there’s a pretty big difference between saying someone shouldn’t spend a small fortune on a speculative immortality procedure and giving up on life. Between the fact that it’s not their life and that cryonics is just freezing a corpse to most of us, don’t expect that to translate into an actual longing for death / despair over life.
Anyway, onto these cryonics dissuaders. Are we talking something like “life would be boring after (Average Life Expectancy in my Country) years, because sour grapes” or “life in a society where you have no useful skills, are completely ignorant and unsocialized, and everyone you know is dead would be distinctly unpleasant” or more of a “Seriously, life is pain bro” kind of thing?
The first is either a clever attempt to get you out of a perceived scam or a rationalization, the second is a fairly good point if debatable, and the third guy just wants weed money. None of them seem like they’ve given up on life.
someone shouldn’t spend a small fortune on a speculative immortality procedure
A very small fortune, since I had already mentioned it would be paid for with life insurance.
the fact that it’s not their life
Did a double-take here. Sorry, I phrased it poorly; we were discussing cryonics in general, with focus on practicality for everyone in the conversation; not just me.
cryonics is just freezing a corpse to most of us
… are your opinions on cryonics by any chance mostly a result of popcultural osmosis? Please don’t be offended, just a shot in the dark.
“life would be boring after (Average Life Expectancy in my Country) years, because sour grapes”
About right, although it was fairly vague.
“life in a society where you have no useful skills, are completely ignorant and unsocialized, and everyone you know is dead would be distinctly unpleasant”
… no. Do people seriously try this? It sounds vaguely familiar, but I’ve never really encountered it… There was a brief “what if everything sucks?” “why would they bring you back if everything sucks?”; that’s about as close as anyone got. (Neither of those voices is me.)
“Seriously, life is pain bro”
I’m not entirely sure what you’re trying to convey with this—are we talking antinatalist-style arguments.
The first is either a clever attempt to get you out of a perceived scam or a rationalization
???
None of them seem like they’ve given up on life.
One assumes that it’s somewhat difficult to debate cryonics with people who have committed suicide, which is what you seem to mean by “given up on life”.
A very small fortune, since I had already mentioned it would be paid for with life insurance.
It seems that insurance increases the expected amount of money that will be paid rather than decreasing it. The benefit of insurance is not a reduction in (expected) cost but a redistribution of money from possible futures where you are fortunate to possible futures where you are unfortunate. This is a service that you pay a premium for.
If you’re talking about Brennan’s world, it’s already driven me a little insane, to the point of having suicidal thoughts. I’m getting better with that now as the rest of your writing is helpful medicine for bad thinking, If I weren’t already very receptive to psychiatric treatment and thankfully had a strong skeptical background, it might not have ended well and the thought that that sort of thing might be going on still bothers me greatly. This was the first time I read this particular post, and it helped me downshift the probability of that such a thing is happening now, but it’s dangerous stuff for certain people (people with high levels of dopamine have a higher tendency to make type one errors, perceiving patterns where there are none, according to Michael Shermer). I think you’re right that the typical person would be fine, but what you might not know is that if you dig deep enough in the conspiracy world there are suicide memes. I am very sure that the vast majority of your readers would be fine, and that for them your stories would be entertaining, even compelling for some, but my two cents is that the disutility is high enough to outweigh that benefit.
I’m sure most of you would be fine, but the question I have to ask is “Will this drive more than 5% of my reading audience insane?”
Necronimicon Light: 95% likely not to drive you insane.
Here’s another question, though: Will it drive 5% of my reading audience sane?
There are people who really, genuinely feel there’s no point in striving to live, because life isn’t nice. Even just showing them that life could be nice might be helpful, when it comes to things like getting signed up for cryonics.
Is showing them a fictional nicer life really actually going to help, here? I mean, I could be wrong—there was that whole religion thing—but I’d think that what people like that need would be a nicer life now and showing them a better world would tend to make them unhappier.
In one very specific case, it well might. It’s someone who will, no question about it, be dead within a year.
His main objection to cryonics seems to be that living isn’t very fun anyway, so why bother. And though I may be playing whack-a-mole with arguments, life is important enough to at least try.
I am curious as to what would happen if he tried reading HPMOR.
I’d just like to say here, that a few months ago, reading the fun theory sequence made me much happier. It was the idea that there was at least one, probably more, good futures, with a clear way of how to get there. Before, I had just assumed that we would all die in some apocalypse, probably from climate change. So thank you.
That’s a great sentiment, but it doesn’t take into account that people who “genuinely feel there’s no point in striving to live” are typically clinically depressed. I.E., have a serious issue with their neurochemistry.
Take it from someone who’s been there; you don’t talk someone out of a depression, at least not unless you’re a psychiatrist with a pad of prescription sheets and training in cognitive behavioral therapy. Or at least an ECT machine and a really kinky looking table. God I love psychiatry.
(If on the other hand we’re just talking about people who are bummed, not actually having given up on life, then yeah I’m sure EY could spin a tale good enough to pick up their spirits.)
I’ve had people try to dissuade me in cryonics discussions on the basis that it simply wouldn’t be worth it, life isn’t that great. I doubt they were clinically depressed. Whether that was their true rejection, on the other hand...
Yeah, there’s a pretty big difference between saying someone shouldn’t spend a small fortune on a speculative immortality procedure and giving up on life. Between the fact that it’s not their life and that cryonics is just freezing a corpse to most of us, don’t expect that to translate into an actual longing for death / despair over life.
Anyway, onto these cryonics dissuaders. Are we talking something like “life would be boring after (Average Life Expectancy in my Country) years, because sour grapes” or “life in a society where you have no useful skills, are completely ignorant and unsocialized, and everyone you know is dead would be distinctly unpleasant” or more of a “Seriously, life is pain bro” kind of thing?
The first is either a clever attempt to get you out of a perceived scam or a rationalization, the second is a fairly good point if debatable, and the third guy just wants weed money. None of them seem like they’ve given up on life.
A very small fortune, since I had already mentioned it would be paid for with life insurance.
Did a double-take here. Sorry, I phrased it poorly; we were discussing cryonics in general, with focus on practicality for everyone in the conversation; not just me.
… are your opinions on cryonics by any chance mostly a result of popcultural osmosis? Please don’t be offended, just a shot in the dark.
About right, although it was fairly vague.
… no. Do people seriously try this? It sounds vaguely familiar, but I’ve never really encountered it… There was a brief “what if everything sucks?” “why would they bring you back if everything sucks?”; that’s about as close as anyone got. (Neither of those voices is me.)
I’m not entirely sure what you’re trying to convey with this—are we talking antinatalist-style arguments.
???
One assumes that it’s somewhat difficult to debate cryonics with people who have committed suicide, which is what you seem to mean by “given up on life”.
They’ve certainly given up on getting more …
It seems that insurance increases the expected amount of money that will be paid rather than decreasing it. The benefit of insurance is not a reduction in (expected) cost but a redistribution of money from possible futures where you are fortunate to possible futures where you are unfortunate. This is a service that you pay a premium for.
Sure. But actually, I was referring to the fact that it doesn’t involve a large lump sum payment, or “fortune”.
Well, it assuaged their doubts about cost, anyhow. Cost was not the issue here.
If you’re talking about Brennan’s world, it’s already driven me a little insane, to the point of having suicidal thoughts. I’m getting better with that now as the rest of your writing is helpful medicine for bad thinking, If I weren’t already very receptive to psychiatric treatment and thankfully had a strong skeptical background, it might not have ended well and the thought that that sort of thing might be going on still bothers me greatly. This was the first time I read this particular post, and it helped me downshift the probability of that such a thing is happening now, but it’s dangerous stuff for certain people (people with high levels of dopamine have a higher tendency to make type one errors, perceiving patterns where there are none, according to Michael Shermer). I think you’re right that the typical person would be fine, but what you might not know is that if you dig deep enough in the conspiracy world there are suicide memes. I am very sure that the vast majority of your readers would be fine, and that for them your stories would be entertaining, even compelling for some, but my two cents is that the disutility is high enough to outweigh that benefit.