It sounds like you’re arguing that there are increasing returns to rationality in groups.
I am not sure. But I think that it would be helpful to think about what experiment would demonstrate the argument you’re making here. e.g. Give a rationality diagnostic exam to a bunch of people, then put them in groups of various sizes and measure how well they perform various tasks.
It sounds like you’re arguing that there are increasing returns to rationality in groups.
I am not sure. But I think that it would be helpful to think about what experiment would demonstrate the argument you’re making here. e.g. Give a rationality diagnostic exam to a bunch of people, then put them in groups of various sizes and measure how well they perform various tasks.
Relatively rational people can form deeply irrational groups, and vice versa.
I would probably take a group with rational institutions but irrational members over a group with irrational institutions but rational members.
Of course, rational people will be better on average at building rational groups, so I would still predict a positive correlation in the experiment.