In his book Lapsuuden kehityksellinen trauma, the psychotherapist Juha Klaavu uses the term “magical guilt” to describe an experience that some people have, where they feel guilty about just about everything. A description that he offers for this is that “when I’m in a park and witness a dog I don’t know biting a person I don’t know, even this seems to somehow be my fault”.
One potential mechanism for magical guilt: “I’m a good person” → “There is a world in which I would have made a difference in this situation” → “I observe I’m not currently in that world” → “The gap between this world and that world is because of my lack of {awareness, action, ambition, energy, etc...}”
The epistemic failure occurring either at step (2) or (4). Either there is no world where you can make a meaningful difference, or the thing that limited your ability to make a difference is entirely out of your control.
One potential mechanism for magical guilt: “I’m a good person” → “There is a world in which I would have made a difference in this situation” → “I observe I’m not currently in that world” → “The gap between this world and that world is because of my lack of {awareness, action, ambition, energy, etc...}”
The epistemic failure occurring either at step (2) or (4). Either there is no world where you can make a meaningful difference, or the thing that limited your ability to make a difference is entirely out of your control.