The field should be a text box, not a radio button or a dropdown list.
Ideally, I’d like it to be labeled ‘pronouns’ rather than ‘gender’, but that might be non-preferred for signaling reasons.
Agree strongly with the signaling concern. Also, it helps prevent smartalecks filling in something like “second person” or worse “first person plural”.
‘Gender’ isn’t much better at dealing with smart-alecks or outliers, actually. If I’m in an odd enough mood on the day that’s implemented, I might fill in the box with ‘yes’. Or ‘no’. Or ‘blue’. ‘Female’ doesn’t always suit me, and unlike with pronouns there’s no obvious non-male non-female answer to that one.
Agree strongly with the signaling concern. Also, it helps prevent smartalecks filling in something like “second person” or worse “first person plural”.
‘Gender’ isn’t much better at dealing with smart-alecks or outliers, actually. If I’m in an odd enough mood on the day that’s implemented, I might fill in the box with ‘yes’. Or ‘no’. Or ‘blue’. ‘Female’ doesn’t always suit me, and unlike with pronouns there’s no obvious non-male non-female answer to that one.