That sort of strategy only works if you can get everyone to coordinate around it, and if you can do that, you could probably just get them to coordinate on doing the right things. I don’t know if HR would listen to you if you brought your concerns directly to them, but they probably aren’t harder to persuade on that sort of thing than convincing the rest of your fellows to defy HR. (Which is just a guess.) In cases where you can’t get others to coordinate on it, you are just defecting against the group, to your own personal loss. This doesn’t seem like a good strategy.
In more limited settings, you might be able to convince your friends to debate things in your preferred style, though this depends on them in particular. As a boss, you might be able to set up a culture where people are expected to make strong arguments in formal settings. Beyond these, I don’t really think it is practical. (They don’t generalize -for instance, as a parent, your child will be incapable of making strong arguments for an extremely long time.)
That sort of strategy only works if you can get everyone to coordinate around it, and if you can do that, you could probably just get them to coordinate on doing the right things. I don’t know if HR would listen to you if you brought your concerns directly to them, but they probably aren’t harder to persuade on that sort of thing than convincing the rest of your fellows to defy HR. (Which is just a guess.) In cases where you can’t get others to coordinate on it, you are just defecting against the group, to your own personal loss. This doesn’t seem like a good strategy.
In more limited settings, you might be able to convince your friends to debate things in your preferred style, though this depends on them in particular. As a boss, you might be able to set up a culture where people are expected to make strong arguments in formal settings. Beyond these, I don’t really think it is practical. (They don’t generalize -for instance, as a parent, your child will be incapable of making strong arguments for an extremely long time.)