Oh, and on the subject of whole brain emulations: Greg Egan’s recent novel Zendegi (despite being, imo, rather poor overall), does make a somewhat convincing case that an emulation of a person’s brain/consciousness/personality might pass something like a Turing test and still not possess subjective consciousness or true general intelligence on a human level.
When this topic comes up I’m always reminded of a bit in John Varley’s Golden Globe, where our hero asks an advanced AI whether it’s actually conscious, and it replies “I’ve thought about that question a lot and have concluded that I’m probably not.”
Oh, and on the subject of whole brain emulations: Greg Egan’s recent novel Zendegi (despite being, imo, rather poor overall), does make a somewhat convincing case that an emulation of a person’s brain/consciousness/personality might pass something like a Turing test and still not possess subjective consciousness or true general intelligence on a human level.
When this topic comes up I’m always reminded of a bit in John Varley’s Golden Globe, where our hero asks an advanced AI whether it’s actually conscious, and it replies “I’ve thought about that question a lot and have concluded that I’m probably not.”