Conditional on the weaker claim that you should join the community, option 5 is tautologically the correct one, you just happened to have phrased it in a way that sounds evil. “Do what is rational” and “do what is in your best interest” both mean “take the most effective actions to optimise your utility function”.
Semi-correct due to further information that you should infer from reality or you would have gotten explicitly with the correct answer of asking for more information. A community has certain expectations when you join it and is likely to take punitive action if you violate those expectations.
As a hint, how is 5 different from 2? Is 2 not rational or not in your best interest?
A community has certain expectations when you join it and is likely to take punitive action if you violate those expectations.
That consequence should factor into your reasoning of “what is in my best interest?”, in the same way why you don’t usually want to perform petty crimes IRL.
As a hint, how is 5 different from 2? Is 2 not rational or not in your best interest?
I read 2 as “I will perform the most rational actions among the subset of those that lead to a net positive for the community”, whereas 5 takes away everything from ‘among’ onwards.
Conditional on the weaker claim that you should join the community, option 5 is tautologically the correct one, you just happened to have phrased it in a way that sounds evil. “Do what is rational” and “do what is in your best interest” both mean “take the most effective actions to optimise your utility function”.
Semi-correct due to further information that you should infer from reality or you would have gotten explicitly with the correct answer of asking for more information. A community has certain expectations when you join it and is likely to take punitive action if you violate those expectations.
As a hint, how is 5 different from 2? Is 2 not rational or not in your best interest?
That consequence should factor into your reasoning of “what is in my best interest?”, in the same way why you don’t usually want to perform petty crimes IRL.
I read 2 as “I will perform the most rational actions among the subset of those that lead to a net positive for the community”, whereas 5 takes away everything from ‘among’ onwards.