I’ll point out that for any criticism to cast meaningful doubt on the results of the Milgram Experiment, it would also have to be applicable to the replication.
Counterpoint: The reviewers are aware of the replication and still seems to lend the book credence
Jerry M. Burger, a psychologist who claimed to have reproduced Milgram’s results. As it happened, Burger had been put up to his act of scientific replication by ABC News, which funded his research and aired footage of his experiments during “The Science of Evil,” a 2007 episode of its Basic Instincts series pegged to the atrocities at Abu Ghraib.
I’m still not convinced that Milgram’s findings are invalid, but short of reading the book I’d like to see some unfavorable reviews from people who have read it before dismissing it.
I’ll point out that for any criticism to cast meaningful doubt on the results of the Milgram Experiment, it would also have to be applicable to the replication.
Counterpoint: The reviewers are aware of the replication and still seems to lend the book credence
and also here:
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/fulfillment-any-age/201301/the-secrets-behind-psychology-s-most-famous-experiment
I’m still not convinced that Milgram’s findings are invalid, but short of reading the book I’d like to see some unfavorable reviews from people who have read it before dismissing it.