It seems very unfortunate to me that the concept of “Blaming the victim” has been founded upon such an ill-advised swipe at that report. Certainly such a phenomenon is painfully apparent all the time in daily life and politics, yet Moynihan’s intentions to me seem neither aggressive or very patronizing, nor even fuelled by conservative ideology, even if it could end up as ammunition for an unscurpulous ideologist. (he was in the Kennedy administration, so he might well have been a liberal technocrat)
Now this is pure conjencture and indeed fantasy on my part, but I guess that Ryan might’ve been motivated by the “Hostile media effect”, assuming that the report was a nefarious reactionary ploy and missing even the fact that Moynihan places nearly all the blame for the cultural dysfunctions of the black community squarely upon white oppression! (Hardly thought of as a right-wing thought pattern.)
I’m not suggesting that such an accusation of American culture and whites’ old behavior towards blacks must conversely be left-wing silliness; the logic of Moynihan’s explanation seems sound enough to me—it might be a cliche, but it’s probably true. (But then, I believe that Noam Chomsky is frequently spot-on and somewhat of an authority—what else is to be expected of me.)
It seems very unfortunate to me that the concept of “Blaming the victim” has been founded upon such an ill-advised swipe at that report. Certainly such a phenomenon is painfully apparent all the time in daily life and politics, yet Moynihan’s intentions to me seem neither aggressive or very patronizing, nor even fuelled by conservative ideology, even if it could end up as ammunition for an unscurpulous ideologist. (he was in the Kennedy administration, so he might well have been a liberal technocrat)
Now this is pure conjencture and indeed fantasy on my part, but I guess that Ryan might’ve been motivated by the “Hostile media effect”, assuming that the report was a nefarious reactionary ploy and missing even the fact that Moynihan places nearly all the blame for the cultural dysfunctions of the black community squarely upon white oppression! (Hardly thought of as a right-wing thought pattern.)
I’m not suggesting that such an accusation of American culture and whites’ old behavior towards blacks must conversely be left-wing silliness; the logic of Moynihan’s explanation seems sound enough to me—it might be a cliche, but it’s probably true. (But then, I believe that Noam Chomsky is frequently spot-on and somewhat of an authority—what else is to be expected of me.)