Ah sorry, I realized that “in expectation” was implied. It seems the same worry applies. “Effects of this sort are very hard to reliably forecast” doesn’t imply “we should set those effects to zero in expectation”. Cf. Greaves’s discussion of complex cluelessness.
Tbc, I don’t think Daniel should beat himself up over this either, if that’s what you mean by “grade yourself”. I’m just saying that insofar as we’re trying to assess the expected effects of an action, the assumption that these kinds of indirect effects cancel out in expectation seems very strong (even if it’s common).
Ah sorry, I realized that “in expectation” was implied. It seems the same worry applies. “Effects of this sort are very hard to reliably forecast” doesn’t imply “we should set those effects to zero in expectation”. Cf. Greaves’s discussion of complex cluelessness.
Tbc, I don’t think Daniel should beat himself up over this either, if that’s what you mean by “grade yourself”. I’m just saying that insofar as we’re trying to assess the expected effects of an action, the assumption that these kinds of indirect effects cancel out in expectation seems very strong (even if it’s common).