That seems false to me, conflicts between humans share a similar structure across different environments, and generalization is to be expected so evidence in a mild domain is at least indicative of extreme domains. Also, as it happens, I have in fact had extensive interactions with one of the listed subgroups, and they do respond in ways that the reasonable generalizations would expect.
Reading your posts I form a story that you have a strong need to fight back against careless epistemics, which looks from my vantage point like it comes with some rigidity, unwillingness to incorporate forms of evidence that are not extremely well-founded into your models, and maybe a tinge of something that my system reads as contained hostility and superiority. It’s not that extreme here, and my priors might well be coloured by watching clashes between you and other site regulars, but engaging with it brings up some discomfort and a sense that I might end up using bandwidth unproductively.
I don’t super have an ask here, but I do think there’s something here which might be useful to some of your future engagements. I imagine it’s not super fun getting into lots of fights, and I think you can get the good you’re seeking of challenging sloppy reasoning without the downsides with a few adjustments.
That seems false to me, conflicts between humans share a similar structure across different environments, and generalization is to be expected so evidence in a mild domain is at least indicative of extreme domains. Also, as it happens, I have in fact had extensive interactions with one of the listed subgroups, and they do respond in ways that the reasonable generalizations would expect.
Reading your posts I form a story that you have a strong need to fight back against careless epistemics, which looks from my vantage point like it comes with some rigidity, unwillingness to incorporate forms of evidence that are not extremely well-founded into your models, and maybe a tinge of something that my system reads as contained hostility and superiority. It’s not that extreme here, and my priors might well be coloured by watching clashes between you and other site regulars, but engaging with it brings up some discomfort and a sense that I might end up using bandwidth unproductively.
I don’t super have an ask here, but I do think there’s something here which might be useful to some of your future engagements. I imagine it’s not super fun getting into lots of fights, and I think you can get the good you’re seeking of challenging sloppy reasoning without the downsides with a few adjustments.