feedback expressing painpoints/emotion is valuable, whereas feedback expressing implementation/solutions is not.
Yep. Or, let’s say that the kind of feedback that provides solutions is worthless 99% of time. Because it is possible in principle to provide a good advice, it’s just that most people do not have the necessary qualification and experience but may be overconfident about their qualification.
I find it ironical that popular wisdom seems to go the other way round, and “constructive criticism” is praised as the right thing to do. Which just doesn’t make sense; for example I can say that a meal tastes bad, even if I don’t know how to cook; or I can complain about pain without being able to cure it.
Yep. Or, let’s say that the kind of feedback that provides solutions is worthless 99% of time. Because it is possible in principle to provide a good advice, it’s just that most people do not have the necessary qualification and experience but may be overconfident about their qualification.
I find it ironical that popular wisdom seems to go the other way round, and “constructive criticism” is praised as the right thing to do. Which just doesn’t make sense; for example I can say that a meal tastes bad, even if I don’t know how to cook; or I can complain about pain without being able to cure it.