Submission. “Overlooked Comment.” For LBO, ask the oracle to find the most overlooked comment (or post) on LW (or some other forum). The set of possible answers is all the existing comments on LW. After getting the answer from the oracle, gather a group of judges and present each of them with the comment picked by the oracle and a few other random comments (without telling them which is which, to reduce bias) and have the judges assign scores to each comment (according to what they think the karma of that comment should be). Reward the oracle according to the difference between the judges’ average score and actual karma of that comment.
Submission. “Overlooked Comment.” For LBO, ask the oracle to find the most overlooked comment (or post) on LW (or some other forum). The set of possible answers is all the existing comments on LW. After getting the answer from the oracle, gather a group of judges and present each of them with the comment picked by the oracle and a few other random comments (without telling them which is which, to reduce bias) and have the judges assign scores to each comment (according to what they think the karma of that comment should be). Reward the oracle according to the difference between the judges’ average score and actual karma of that comment.
Comment looked at. Query completed.