I prob. would have been slightly clearer in the conclusion that this is really only a starting point as it identifies issues where at least N people thought it was an issue, but it doesn’t (by design) tell us what the rest thought, so we don’t really know if these are majority or minority views.
Just to add my personal opinion: I agree with some of the criticisms (including empirical work being underrated for a long time although maybe not now and excessive pessimism on policy). However, for many of the other, I they might seem like obvious mistakes at first, but once you dig into the details it becomes a bit more complicated.
I prob. would have been slightly clearer in the conclusion that this is really only a starting point as it identifies issues where at least N people thought it was an issue, but it doesn’t (by design) tell us what the rest thought, so we don’t really know if these are majority or minority views.
Just to add my personal opinion: I agree with some of the criticisms (including empirical work being underrated for a long time although maybe not now and excessive pessimism on policy). However, for many of the other, I they might seem like obvious mistakes at first, but once you dig into the details it becomes a bit more complicated.