Agree with this. I think this kind of work is fantastic, and I’m really glad it was shared.
Even if it is the case that you are just doing something wrong, its good to share because it useful to figure out what that is. The fact that you tried hard to replicate something and you couldn’t get it to work is really a finding within itself (because it may show that getting the results requires something subtle that wasn’t documented and isn’t obvious).
Nice, good to know.
In general, I support failed replications as top level posts.
Agree with this. I think this kind of work is fantastic, and I’m really glad it was shared.
Even if it is the case that you are just doing something wrong, its good to share because it useful to figure out what that is. The fact that you tried hard to replicate something and you couldn’t get it to work is really a finding within itself (because it may show that getting the results requires something subtle that wasn’t documented and isn’t obvious).