Hm. On the one hand, I agree that there are distinct things at play here and share the instinct that it’d be appropriate to have different words for these different things. But on the other hand, I’m not sure if the different words should fall under the umbrella of solitude, like “romantic solitude” and “seeing human faces solitude”.
I dunno, maybe it should. After all, it seems that in different conceptualizations of solitude, it’s about being isolated from something (others’ minds, others’ physical presence).
Ultimately, I’m trusting Newport here. I think highly of him and know that he’s read a lot of relevant literature. At the same time, I still wouldn’t argue too confidently that his preferred definition is the most useful one.
Hm. On the one hand, I agree that there are distinct things at play here and share the instinct that it’d be appropriate to have different words for these different things. But on the other hand, I’m not sure if the different words should fall under the umbrella of solitude, like “romantic solitude” and “seeing human faces solitude”.
I dunno, maybe it should. After all, it seems that in different conceptualizations of solitude, it’s about being isolated from something (others’ minds, others’ physical presence).
Ultimately, I’m trusting Newport here. I think highly of him and know that he’s read a lot of relevant literature. At the same time, I still wouldn’t argue too confidently that his preferred definition is the most useful one.