i think this is a bit overblown, from observing academia you can definitely trade a small amount of status for academic freedom if you’re not 90th-percentile disagreeable. You could go to a slightly lower-ranked but still R1 school, and negotiate for ability to do whatever you want. If the school isn’t trying hard to climb rankings, there’s less pressure to publish or to measure performance based on strange status-y things. You do lose out on some amount of status compared to being at a top school, but if you do good work your peers at top schools will still read/pay attention to it. At top schools, negotiating for freedom is much harder to do because the market is more competitive and ppl play status games to get ahead on the margin.
i think this is a bit overblown, from observing academia you can definitely trade a small amount of status for academic freedom if you’re not 90th-percentile disagreeable. You could go to a slightly lower-ranked but still R1 school, and negotiate for ability to do whatever you want. If the school isn’t trying hard to climb rankings, there’s less pressure to publish or to measure performance based on strange status-y things. You do lose out on some amount of status compared to being at a top school, but if you do good work your peers at top schools will still read/pay attention to it. At top schools, negotiating for freedom is much harder to do because the market is more competitive and ppl play status games to get ahead on the margin.