Small nitpick: I don’t like your use of the word ‘certainty’ here. Especially in philosophy, it has too much of a connotation of “literally impossible for me to be wrong” rather than “so ridiculously unlikely that I’m wrong that we can just ignore it”, which may cause confusion.
Where don’t you like it? I don’t think anyone actually argues for your first definition, because, like I said, it’s silly. I think curi’s point is that fallibilism is predicated on your second definition not (ever?) being a valid claim.
My point is that the things we are “certain” about (as per your second definition) probably coincide almost exactly with “statements without criticism” as per curi’s definition(s).
It is a silly definition, but people are silly enough that I hear it often enough to be wary of it.
My point is that the things we are “certain” about (as per your second definition) probably coincide almost exactly with “statements without criticism” as per curi’s definition(s).
I interpreted this as the first definition. I guess we should see what curi says.
Small nitpick: I don’t like your use of the word ‘certainty’ here. Especially in philosophy, it has too much of a connotation of “literally impossible for me to be wrong” rather than “so ridiculously unlikely that I’m wrong that we can just ignore it”, which may cause confusion.
Where don’t you like it? I don’t think anyone actually argues for your first definition, because, like I said, it’s silly. I think curi’s point is that fallibilism is predicated on your second definition not (ever?) being a valid claim.
My point is that the things we are “certain” about (as per your second definition) probably coincide almost exactly with “statements without criticism” as per curi’s definition(s).
It is a silly definition, but people are silly enough that I hear it often enough to be wary of it.
I interpreted this as the first definition. I guess we should see what curi says.
people genrally try to have their cake and eat it: they want certainty to mean “cannot be wrong”, but only on the basis that they feel sure.