if we aren’t more successful or interesting than other people then we probably don’t have much worth talking to them about
I would like to convince other people to play the same game as me. Rather than having very smart people thinking about how to solve some arbitrarily selected hard problem, I would rather they take a step back and make a desperate effort on humanity’s behalf.
I think this is true regardless of whether I am more successful or interesting than they are.
if we aren’t more successful or interesting than other people then we probably don’t have much worth talking to them about
and
I would like to convince other people to play the same game as me. Rather than having very smart people thinking about how to solve some arbitrarily selected hard problem, I would rather they take a step back and make a desperate effort on humanity’s behalf.
I don’t think that these two ideas are at all contradictory. Ideally, we’d want people to to step back and try and help humanity, but in reality I think it would probably be very helpful to the goal of getting more rationalists (maybe even necessary?) for rationalists to be clearly successful.
I would like to convince other people to play the same game as me. Rather than having very smart people thinking about how to solve some arbitrarily selected hard problem, I would rather they take a step back and make a desperate effort on humanity’s behalf.
I think this is true regardless of whether I am more successful or interesting than they are.
and
I don’t think that these two ideas are at all contradictory. Ideally, we’d want people to to step back and try and help humanity, but in reality I think it would probably be very helpful to the goal of getting more rationalists (maybe even necessary?) for rationalists to be clearly successful.