Right, but if I had an effect that depended on massed belief, I’d be pretty sure that existed too.
Say, Discworld-style gods.
(Things that depend on individual belief generally have a low enough prior that I’m probably dreaming/hallucinating, and also I can’t tell myself to stop believing in things so whatever it is I think I’m doing it’s not “not believing in X”.)
Sure. When we’re looking at socially constructed stuff, though, I’m not sure it makes sense to treat its reality as discrete rather than continuous.
It’s tempting to use money as a measure of social reality, actually, since it’s valuable directly in proportion to people’s belief in its value. Unfortunately it’s hard to put a dollar value on, say, traffic laws, which share the same property (a point driven home for me the first time I encountered rush-hour traffic in Manila).
That’s because the gas station owner still believes in the value of the dollar. But if all of you stopped believing in it...
Right, but if I had an effect that depended on massed belief, I’d be pretty sure that existed too.
Say, Discworld-style gods.
(Things that depend on individual belief generally have a low enough prior that I’m probably dreaming/hallucinating, and also I can’t tell myself to stop believing in things so whatever it is I think I’m doing it’s not “not believing in X”.)
Sure. When we’re looking at socially constructed stuff, though, I’m not sure it makes sense to treat its reality as discrete rather than continuous.
It’s tempting to use money as a measure of social reality, actually, since it’s valuable directly in proportion to people’s belief in its value. Unfortunately it’s hard to put a dollar value on, say, traffic laws, which share the same property (a point driven home for me the first time I encountered rush-hour traffic in Manila).