This time, the atheists have a way to either escape from the brutality of religious oppression, or to overthrow it in a limited fashion.
I think it was Cyril Kornbluth who wrote the Story The Marching Morons where normal society was… a bunch of morons. The society had another side though, anyone who showed the slightest real intelligence was whisked off to live as the real power behind society.
While that was a fictionalization of a fear that the ignorant and stupid would out breed the smarter and better educated (a very real fear in my opinion), it did show something that is rapidly becoming the case. There are a great many technologies that require some pretty sophisticated knowledge to continue functioning. eventually society may get to the point where the intelligentsia may be able to hold the ignorant and stupid members of society (no matter how powerful) for ransom via the technologies controlled by the intelligentsia. It may not be obvious, explicit power, yet it is not something that should be overlooked.
eventually society may get to the point where the intelligentsia may be able to hold
the ignorant and stupid members of society (no matter how powerful) for ransom
via the technologies controlled by the intelligentsia
I do not know one way or the other at this point. From a recent NYT article about the Tea Party Movement, it seems the populace of the USA thinks that this is already the case.
eventually society may get to the point where the intelligentsia may be able to hold the ignorant and stupid members of society (no matter how powerful) for ransom via the technologies controlled by the intelligentsia
I believe the Unabomber Manifesto makes a similar claim. It’s worth reading.
The Unabomber manifesto is an incredibly dense piece of prose. I found it hard to get through, but you are correct. Ted lived in mortal fear of the Intelligentsia being in control because he thought that they were all as psychopathic as he. I would fear a bunch of emotionless robots who hated humanity in charge even if they did run everything in as rational a fashion as possible.
It is likely that the educated and intelligent elite will one day in fact control most of the wealth in the world, and by de facto the actual running of the world under nearly impotent governmental cover. I think that this may well be a side-effect of the Singularity, and if a Friendly AI is indeed developed, it may wind up being very much like The Forbin Project (Except that the AI will not need to threaten us, as it will probably be fantastically capable of just manipulating the masses into the behavior it wishes).
As long as basic freedoms are preserved, I could care less if we were governed by a mindless mob, a group of super-geniuses, or ducks pecking at a light board to play tic-tac-toe to cast legislation.
This time, the atheists have a way to either escape from the brutality of religious oppression, or to overthrow it in a limited fashion.
I think it was Cyril Kornbluth who wrote the Story The Marching Morons where normal society was… a bunch of morons. The society had another side though, anyone who showed the slightest real intelligence was whisked off to live as the real power behind society.
While that was a fictionalization of a fear that the ignorant and stupid would out breed the smarter and better educated (a very real fear in my opinion), it did show something that is rapidly becoming the case. There are a great many technologies that require some pretty sophisticated knowledge to continue functioning. eventually society may get to the point where the intelligentsia may be able to hold the ignorant and stupid members of society (no matter how powerful) for ransom via the technologies controlled by the intelligentsia. It may not be obvious, explicit power, yet it is not something that should be overlooked.
Are you in favor of this development or opposed?
I do not know one way or the other at this point. From a recent NYT article about the Tea Party Movement, it seems the populace of the USA thinks that this is already the case.
I believe the Unabomber Manifesto makes a similar claim. It’s worth reading.
The Unabomber manifesto is an incredibly dense piece of prose. I found it hard to get through, but you are correct. Ted lived in mortal fear of the Intelligentsia being in control because he thought that they were all as psychopathic as he. I would fear a bunch of emotionless robots who hated humanity in charge even if they did run everything in as rational a fashion as possible.
It is likely that the educated and intelligent elite will one day in fact control most of the wealth in the world, and by de facto the actual running of the world under nearly impotent governmental cover. I think that this may well be a side-effect of the Singularity, and if a Friendly AI is indeed developed, it may wind up being very much like The Forbin Project (Except that the AI will not need to threaten us, as it will probably be fantastically capable of just manipulating the masses into the behavior it wishes).
As long as basic freedoms are preserved, I could care less if we were governed by a mindless mob, a group of super-geniuses, or ducks pecking at a light board to play tic-tac-toe to cast legislation.