Well yes but there is quite a big difference between having moral standards and actually living up to them enough to think of oneself as “good”. At least in my brain truly “good” people are very rare.
Haha, the thing is, I was raised partly on D&D, which was my first source of a metaethical theory, and there, at least in theory, much of alignment is defined by intentions (at least, that’s how I read it in my teenage years). Then again, I might have twisted that a bit to conform to my own beliefs. Either way, I grew up believing that e.g. a witch who has never actually hurt anyone personally but helps an evil tribe and would betray marauding “heroes” to them can indeed be “Lawful Evil”, and, consequentially, a con artist who’s sensitive, guilt-ridden and helps the poor sometimes can indeed be “Chaotic Good” (Oskar Schindler—the real one, not Spielberg’s flat copy—is a hero for me, his case feels incredibly heart-warming). It’s a carticature of my actual feelings, of course, but nonetheless I’m attracted to what is derisively called comic-book morality; I find it, at the very least, better for society than e.g. “rational egoism” informed with Hansonian theory.
Well yes but there is quite a big difference between having moral standards and actually living up to them enough to think of oneself as “good”. At least in my brain truly “good” people are very rare.
Haha, the thing is, I was raised partly on D&D, which was my first source of a metaethical theory, and there, at least in theory, much of alignment is defined by intentions (at least, that’s how I read it in my teenage years). Then again, I might have twisted that a bit to conform to my own beliefs. Either way, I grew up believing that e.g. a witch who has never actually hurt anyone personally but helps an evil tribe and would betray marauding “heroes” to them can indeed be “Lawful Evil”, and, consequentially, a con artist who’s sensitive, guilt-ridden and helps the poor sometimes can indeed be “Chaotic Good” (Oskar Schindler—the real one, not Spielberg’s flat copy—is a hero for me, his case feels incredibly heart-warming). It’s a carticature of my actual feelings, of course, but nonetheless I’m attracted to what is derisively called comic-book morality; I find it, at the very least, better for society than e.g. “rational egoism” informed with Hansonian theory.