However, you have stated that you do not predict punishment, so there is something wrong with your decision process.
Or perhaps with my understanding of the original problem, or its wording. At this point I am not clear who knows what when, and who gets punished under what circumstances.
Honestly, I’ve probably made it more confusing by editing the wording as I go. One thing that might make it easier is the dot points I’ve now added in my post that describe the situation step-by-step. I wish I’d thought of including that at the start.
Or perhaps with my understanding of the original problem, or its wording. At this point I am not clear who knows what when, and who gets punished under what circumstances.
Honestly, I’ve probably made it more confusing by editing the wording as I go. One thing that might make it easier is the dot points I’ve now added in my post that describe the situation step-by-step. I wish I’d thought of including that at the start.