I feel like there’s a small inferential gap between the Ayn Rand anecdote and the Objectivist failure mode as you’ve presented it: the anecdote establishes unjustified personal antipathy on the part of a group leader, but, absent context, that doesn’t lead inevitably to its target getting voted off the island.
People who’ve read about the history of Objectivism would probably be able to fill this gap with their own knowledge. People who’ve internalized Objectivism’s reputation as a cult would probably fill it with an assumption (a correct one, as it turns out). But I don’t think those sets cover the space of possible readers all that well.
I feel like there’s a small inferential gap between the Ayn Rand anecdote and the Objectivist failure mode as you’ve presented it: the anecdote establishes unjustified personal antipathy on the part of a group leader, but, absent context, that doesn’t lead inevitably to its target getting voted off the island.
People who’ve read about the history of Objectivism would probably be able to fill this gap with their own knowledge. People who’ve internalized Objectivism’s reputation as a cult would probably fill it with an assumption (a correct one, as it turns out). But I don’t think those sets cover the space of possible readers all that well.
True. I didn’t understand how the anecdote related to the article, although Daniel Burfoot’s comment helped to clarify.