“Classic flavor” JTB is indeed that bad. JTB shifted to a probabilistic ontology is either Bayesian, wrong, or answering a different question altogether.
I’ll go for answering different questions. Bayes, although well known to mainstream academia , isn’t regarded as the one epistemology to rule them all , precisely because there are so many issues it doesn’t address.
It remains the case that JTB isn’t that bad, and Bayes isn’t that good a substitute.
“Classic flavor” JTB is indeed that bad. JTB shifted to a probabilistic ontology is either Bayesian, wrong, or answering a different question altogether.
I’ll go for answering different questions. Bayes, although well known to mainstream academia , isn’t regarded as the one epistemology to rule them all , precisely because there are so many issues it doesn’t address.