Thanks for the write up. I was a participant in both Hypermind and XPT, but I recused myself from the MMLU question (among others) because I knew the GPT-4 result many months before the public. I’m not too surprised Hypermind was the least accurate—I think the traders there are less informed, plus the interface for shaping the distribution is a bit lacking (my recollection is that last year’s version capped the width of distributions which massively constrained some predictions). I recall they also plotted the current values, a generally nice feature which has the side effect of anchoring ignorant forecasters downward, I’d bet.
Question: Are the Hypermind results for 2023 just from forecasts in 2022, or do they include forecasts from the prior year as well? I’m curious if part of the poor accuracy is from stale forecasts that were never updated.
I was a participant in both Hypermind and XPT, but I recused myself from the MMLU question (among others) because I knew the GPT-4 result many months before the public.
This is a prediction market not a stock market, insider trading is highly encouraged. Don’t know about Jacob but I’d rather have more accurate predictions in my prediction market.
Strongly disagree. Employees of OpenAI and their alpha tester partners have obligations not to reveal secret information, whether by prediction market or other mechanism. Insider trading is not a sin against the market; it’s a sin against the entity that entrusted you with private information. If someone tells me information under an NDA, I am obligated not to trade on that information.
Thanks for the write up. I was a participant in both Hypermind and XPT, but I recused myself from the MMLU question (among others) because I knew the GPT-4 result many months before the public. I’m not too surprised Hypermind was the least accurate—I think the traders there are less informed, plus the interface for shaping the distribution is a bit lacking (my recollection is that last year’s version capped the width of distributions which massively constrained some predictions). I recall they also plotted the current values, a generally nice feature which has the side effect of anchoring ignorant forecasters downward, I’d bet.
Question: Are the Hypermind results for 2023 just from forecasts in 2022, or do they include forecasts from the prior year as well? I’m curious if part of the poor accuracy is from stale forecasts that were never updated.
This is a prediction market not a stock market, insider trading is highly encouraged. Don’t know about Jacob but I’d rather have more accurate predictions in my prediction market.
Strongly disagree. Employees of OpenAI and their alpha tester partners have obligations not to reveal secret information, whether by prediction market or other mechanism. Insider trading is not a sin against the market; it’s a sin against the entity that entrusted you with private information. If someone tells me information under an NDA, I am obligated not to trade on that information.