Agreed. All I’m really saying is “For God’s sake, people, there’s enough evidence here to have a look, surely?”
We do have Broda Barnes’ word that taking desiccated thyroid long-term isn’t that bad for people. He really does seem to have put people on thyroid at the slightest excuse, and he reckoned that his patient records showed them being healthier than the general population, especially for things like heart disease. Which is kind of weird given that his patients were the sort of people who went to see a doctor and got put on lifetime medication.
Maybe only the really healthy could survive his methods and everyone else scurried back to more conventional doctors who would sensibly tell them it was all their fault for fancying their parents? Increasingly I think that psychiatry has the same advantage as homeopathy, in that it can’t possibly have any effect so they’re not going to hurt people.
I don’t know how seriously to take Barnes. Originally I thought he must have been a bit of a lunatic, until I ended up coming up with the idea above, which pretty much makes his observations as predictions. Then I read his book, and it said exactly what I thought it would say.
I disagree with his ‘origin story’, that the strange widespread hypothyroidism of modern times is because people aren’t dying of infections any more. (He thought that hypothyroid children were prone to infections and so they’d have all died of tuberculosis before they became adults. I think that a ‘genetic proneness to infection’ would have bred out very quickly.)
But again, if he was handing out thyroid meds to people who already had enough of the stuff naturally, that should have hurt them, not made them less prone to illness.
He might have been a fraud, but it seems a weird thing to do..… Even if he was just disregarding his patients’ complaints because he had given them thyroid and so they were damned well better, whatever they thought, he should have noticed them dying of heart attacks.
But I don’t really trust anyone medical any more. And Barnes was an endocrinologist.
Agreed. All I’m really saying is “For God’s sake, people, there’s enough evidence here to have a look, surely?”
We do have Broda Barnes’ word that taking desiccated thyroid long-term isn’t that bad for people. He really does seem to have put people on thyroid at the slightest excuse, and he reckoned that his patient records showed them being healthier than the general population, especially for things like heart disease. Which is kind of weird given that his patients were the sort of people who went to see a doctor and got put on lifetime medication.
Maybe only the really healthy could survive his methods and everyone else scurried back to more conventional doctors who would sensibly tell them it was all their fault for fancying their parents? Increasingly I think that psychiatry has the same advantage as homeopathy, in that it can’t possibly have any effect so they’re not going to hurt people.
I don’t know how seriously to take Barnes. Originally I thought he must have been a bit of a lunatic, until I ended up coming up with the idea above, which pretty much makes his observations as predictions. Then I read his book, and it said exactly what I thought it would say.
I disagree with his ‘origin story’, that the strange widespread hypothyroidism of modern times is because people aren’t dying of infections any more. (He thought that hypothyroid children were prone to infections and so they’d have all died of tuberculosis before they became adults. I think that a ‘genetic proneness to infection’ would have bred out very quickly.)
But again, if he was handing out thyroid meds to people who already had enough of the stuff naturally, that should have hurt them, not made them less prone to illness.
He might have been a fraud, but it seems a weird thing to do..… Even if he was just disregarding his patients’ complaints because he had given them thyroid and so they were damned well better, whatever they thought, he should have noticed them dying of heart attacks.
But I don’t really trust anyone medical any more. And Barnes was an endocrinologist.