Totally appreciate you guys have a lot on your plate right now! At least two of the examples I mentioned in my top-level comment didn’t seem like misrepresentations to me (though two of them did), which makes me confused as to how much of this post is accurate if it really is saying that all of the quoted examples are misrepresentations (hence the reason for my comment requesting that clarification). I haven’t carefully dug into every claim myself but overall my sense is that this post very heavily blurs the line between vehement disagreement and actual misrepresentation such that I don’t feel there’s a clear takeaway for me about how much of each is going on in Séb’s critique.
Totally appreciate you guys have a lot on your plate right now! At least two of the examples I mentioned in my top-level comment didn’t seem like misrepresentations to me (though two of them did), which makes me confused as to how much of this post is accurate if it really is saying that all of the quoted examples are misrepresentations (hence the reason for my comment requesting that clarification). I haven’t carefully dug into every claim myself but overall my sense is that this post very heavily blurs the line between vehement disagreement and actual misrepresentation such that I don’t feel there’s a clear takeaway for me about how much of each is going on in Séb’s critique.