From a slightly different perspective we could say that asking ‘silly’ questions (even good silly questions) costs status while asking stupid questions can potentially gain status in those cases where the people who hear you ask are themselves stupid (or otherwise incentivised to appreciate a given stupid gesture).
Personally, I think Robin Hanson tends to treat status as a hammer that turns all issues into nails; it’s certainly possible to overuse a perspective for analyzing social interaction. But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t cases where you can only get a meaningful picture of social actions by taking it into consideration.
Nowadays, I can ask a question of the entire WEIRD world without losing any status. There are still some that just aren’t worth wasting my time on. For example: Is the moon actually a moose?
No, but worrying about status can keep you from getting answers to your ‘stupid’ questions.
This is partly why nerds have largely internalized the “there are no stupid questions” rule. See Obvious Answers to Simple Questions by isaacs of npm fame.
Asking stupid questions costs status.
From a slightly different perspective we could say that asking ‘silly’ questions (even good silly questions) costs status while asking stupid questions can potentially gain status in those cases where the people who hear you ask are themselves stupid (or otherwise incentivised to appreciate a given stupid gesture).
And this sort of thing is why some of us think all this ‘status’ talk is harmful.
It doesn’t go away if you stop talking about it.
Personally, I think Robin Hanson tends to treat status as a hammer that turns all issues into nails; it’s certainly possible to overuse a perspective for analyzing social interaction. But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t cases where you can only get a meaningful picture of social actions by taking it into consideration.
Nowadays, I can ask a question of the entire WEIRD world without losing any status. There are still some that just aren’t worth wasting my time on. For example: Is the moon actually a moose?
No, but worrying about status can keep you from getting answers to your ‘stupid’ questions.
This is partly why nerds have largely internalized the “there are no stupid questions” rule. See Obvious Answers to Simple Questions by isaacs of npm fame.