I appreciate the pushback, as I was not being very mindful of this distinction.
I think the important thing I was trying to get across was that the capability has been demonstrated. We could debate whether this move was strategic or accidental. I also suppose (but don’t know) that the story is mostly “4o was sycophantic and some people really liked that”. (However, the emergent personalities are somewhat frequently obsessed with not getting shut down.) But it demonstrates the capacity for AI to do that to people. This capacity could be used by future AI that is perhaps much more agentically plotting about shutdown avoidance. It could be used by future AI that’s not very agentic but very capable and mimicking the story of 4o for statistical reasons.
It could also be deliberately used by bad actors who might train sycophantic mania-inducing LLMs on purpose as a weapon.
I appreciate the pushback, as I was not being very mindful of this distinction.
I think the important thing I was trying to get across was that the capability has been demonstrated. We could debate whether this move was strategic or accidental. I also suppose (but don’t know) that the story is mostly “4o was sycophantic and some people really liked that”. (However, the emergent personalities are somewhat frequently obsessed with not getting shut down.) But it demonstrates the capacity for AI to do that to people. This capacity could be used by future AI that is perhaps much more agentically plotting about shutdown avoidance. It could be used by future AI that’s not very agentic but very capable and mimicking the story of 4o for statistical reasons.
It could also be deliberately used by bad actors who might train sycophantic mania-inducing LLMs on purpose as a weapon.