Quirrel squished Rita of his own accord for his own purposes and Harry’s presence there is damn near irrelevant.
Kinda-sort of.
Harry inadvertently gave Fred&George the idea of making up rumours about Quirrel (by telling them he doesn’t like rumours, and asking them to leave Quirrel out of it). Which Rita Skeeter published.
And the prank he actually commissioned gave Quirrel a plausible explanation for Rita Skeeter’s disappearance.
Morally Harry is not really responsible IMO. But causally, eh… her death would have probably not have happened if he hadn’t talked to the Weasley twins about her.
Morally he still deliberately ruined her, regardless of whether he thought it would cause her death. Doing something to ruin the reputation of someone who lives by their reputation is morally bad even if you didn’t think through all the consequences.
Morally he still deliberately fucked her, regardless of whether he thought it would cause her death.
Different language would be more appropriate to the context. Not because I have qualms with foul language, but because I actually got the impression that we were considering rape-ethics or philosophy in magic-mediated edge cases till I followed the link.
Only if she doesn’t deserve to have her reputation wrecked. Skeeter did—I don’t think Quirrell’s murder is justified, but the phrases he had Harry repeat are all basically accurate.
Kinda-sort of.
Harry inadvertently gave Fred&George the idea of making up rumours about Quirrel (by telling them he doesn’t like rumours, and asking them to leave Quirrel out of it). Which Rita Skeeter published.
And the prank he actually commissioned gave Quirrel a plausible explanation for Rita Skeeter’s disappearance.
Morally Harry is not really responsible IMO. But causally, eh… her death would have probably not have happened if he hadn’t talked to the Weasley twins about her.
Morally he still deliberately ruined her, regardless of whether he thought it would cause her death. Doing something to ruin the reputation of someone who lives by their reputation is morally bad even if you didn’t think through all the consequences.
--edited for language and clarity.
Different language would be more appropriate to the context. Not because I have qualms with foul language, but because I actually got the impression that we were considering rape-ethics or philosophy in magic-mediated edge cases till I followed the link.
thanks
Only if she doesn’t deserve to have her reputation wrecked. Skeeter did—I don’t think Quirrell’s murder is justified, but the phrases he had Harry repeat are all basically accurate.
The irony of this statement is overwhelming—I do hope it’s deliberate.