It looks to me like my list is well-supported by the evidence… But this is a bit of a digression; I can’t do a very thorough investigation into the scientific origins of religious belief. I think I have shown sufficient evidence to cast doubt on the assertion that we don’t have a “religion-shaped hole” to fill.
I’m not asking you to do a thorough investigation—I’m suggesting that you’ve put too much credence in one possible explanation when there are alternative less or equally complex explanations.
For example, a “life’s meaning”-shaped hole in one’s brain seems more plausible than a specifically religion-shaped hole. The features on your list may be characteristics of religions that make them particularly good at appearing to convey meaning (or at taking advantage of flaws in human cognition; or at generating a fear-based response; or… etc.). In short, the listed features make religions fit memes—no religion-shaped hole required. I regard this as a simpler hyphothesis that equally well explains the available facts.
It would be a mistake to proceed as if the available information confirmed the religion-shaped-hole hypothesis. It’s plausible—but that’s all.
Roko wrote:
I’m not asking you to do a thorough investigation—I’m suggesting that you’ve put too much credence in one possible explanation when there are alternative less or equally complex explanations.
For example, a “life’s meaning”-shaped hole in one’s brain seems more plausible than a specifically religion-shaped hole. The features on your list may be characteristics of religions that make them particularly good at appearing to convey meaning (or at taking advantage of flaws in human cognition; or at generating a fear-based response; or… etc.). In short, the listed features make religions fit memes—no religion-shaped hole required. I regard this as a simpler hyphothesis that equally well explains the available facts.
It would be a mistake to proceed as if the available information confirmed the religion-shaped-hole hypothesis. It’s plausible—but that’s all.