Conversely, for those who do not believe, it’s irresistible to discard anything that flies too close to the black hole, as it will get pattern-matched against other false positives that have been previously debunked, coupled again with limitations of memory and processing.
Like the boy who cried wolf.
My only worry about this framing it it assumes that the core premise of the black hole has a better-than-chance likelyhood of being the explanation. Sometimes that is the case, sure, any sports fan is probably tired of clickbait headlines about ‘rumours’ of trades of players and teams or “huge announcements” that turn out to be brand extensions like a Tequila . Such they may just discard anything that suggests it. Every once in a while, though, “wow, Lewis Hamilton actually did sign with Ferrari”. (And even then, this is conflating a class with specific instances: the baseline chance of a successful player changing team might be very low, but the hypothesis that this player will move to that team because of XYZ might in isolation be a convincing premise. “UFOs” is a class too, so I see your concern).
Like the boy who cried wolf.
My only worry about this framing it it assumes that the core premise of the black hole has a better-than-chance likelyhood of being the explanation. Sometimes that is the case, sure, any sports fan is probably tired of clickbait headlines about ‘rumours’ of trades of players and teams or “huge announcements” that turn out to be brand extensions like a Tequila . Such they may just discard anything that suggests it. Every once in a while, though, “wow, Lewis Hamilton actually did sign with Ferrari”. (And even then, this is conflating a class with specific instances: the baseline chance of a successful player changing team might be very low, but the hypothesis that this player will move to that team because of XYZ might in isolation be a convincing premise. “UFOs” is a class too, so I see your concern).
In my mind, what gives the black hole its mass is just how pervasive of a meme it is. That likely has some correlation with truth, but far from 1.